Julian Pottage
Forum Replies Created
-
Posts
-
Sorry I am not familiar with the name Helvic but if it requires West’s pass to be forcing then it is a crazy convention to play. West has shown a limited hand and it is up to East to decide what to do.
It is not a common treatment, though it does have some merit. Playing transfers does mean you cannot play in 2C. The transfer makes the strong doubling hand declarer but also means the weaker defending hand has the lead. I did not know that phone apps could play bridge. One learns something every day!
With this hand I would respond 1H. If partner rebids 1S, you can then bid NT.
If you respond 2C, what do you do next after the likely 2D rebid? If you bid 2H, you are taking the bidding higher and higher on a misfit. If you pass, you could be in a 5-1 diamond ‘fit’ when you have a 4-4 heart fit.
You and your partner need to agree on whether a double from you here is takeout or penalty. If you have agreed it is for takeout then your double is fine and your partner should not have passed. It sounds like you had not discussed what the double would mean. Therefore, since Bernard recommends playing double as for penalties, it would be reasonable for partner to think you have made a penalty double. If in doubt, avoid making an action that you know you and your partner have not discussed.
In the olden days a simple non-reverse change of suit rebid at the two level was not forcing. These days it is usual to play that after a two level response a new suit rebid by opener is forcing. This being the case, it is indeed unnecessary for opener to jump to show a strong hand, so the jump is available as a splinter bid.
1NT here shows a good 7 to a poor 10 with at least one spade stopper and without heart support. With a weaker hand, you pass. If you do not have a spade stopper, you double.
If you play 5-card Stayman, I would treat the opening hand as 23 balanced. Sometimes you would add a point for a 5-card suit but the spot cards are poor and the short diamond honours are not pulling pull weight. In my methods a 2NT opening shows 22-23 so the auction would be 2NT-3D-3S-3NT – opener’s 3S shows 5 spades and a doubleton heart – it is not a super acceptance of the transfer.
If you do not play 5-card Stayman, I would treat the opening hand as unbalanced, so playing Benji that means a 2D opening. Responder bids 2H negative and opener rebids 2S. Responder might then make a second negative (it is good to play 3C rather than 2S for this purpose) and perhaps bid 3H. All routes seem to lead to 3NT. With the strength concentrated in one hand 3NT might not make but with 26 HCP between the two hands is is hard to avoid being in it.
It is usual to play 2D as the negative to a 2C opener. This does indeed keep the bidding lower.
You cannot pass a 2C opening because you do not know what partner’s suit is.
I am wondering whether your question is actually about responder’s second bid.
For overcalls of special bids the usual rule is ‘weak over strong, strong over weak’. What this means is that if an opponent opens a weak two then an overcall shows a decent hand. North’s 3NT was very cautious given that South had shown opening values. 6NT is more accurate valuation than 3NT.
Stayman works best on hands with 4-card majors. Starting with a transfer is usually right when you have a 5-card major. You transfer into spades and then bids hearts naturally twice, you will show 5-5 in the majors.
Partner would not have made 11 tricks on a diamond lead in 3NT. Quite often 3NT would go down, losing four diamonds and a spade.
With only 3 HCP I pass. While double followed by bidding hearts would show a hand with long hearts too weak to bid 2H immediately, partner will not expect as little as this.
