Brian Davies

Forum Replies Created

Viewing 15 posts - 556 through 570 (of 1,123 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • in reply to: Beginner / Intermediate book #25028
    Brian DaviesBrian Davies
    Participant

      Steve, I have a copy of The Right Way To Play Bridge – I picked up many books second hand. I’m sorry, but much of the advice in that book is hopelessly out of date.

      My copy states that it was first published in 1994 and completely revised in 2008. But it doesn’t seem to include transfer responses to no trump openings and other basic stuff that club players have been playing for many decades. This book seems to be a museum piece and has been since it was first published!

      in reply to: Friday Quiz 041 #25017
      Brian DaviesBrian Davies
      Participant

        I regard pass as a descriptive call. If you have our agreements then it limits the hand (no more than 14 HCPs), no sixth spade, no diamond support, so some length in their suits (likely hearts as East has clubs). East will protect with a double and we will defend. So I am happy that our methods will work on this particular hand.

        I’m not saying that these methods will always work better, but they do fill a gap in the system – what to do with strong NT hands in competitive auctions.

        in reply to: Beginner / Intermediate book #24991
        Brian DaviesBrian Davies
        Participant

          Are you looking for a book specifically on bidding? There are a few options of Acol books aimed at beginner level. I would recommend an EBU publication Really Easy Modern Acol by Sandra Landy.

          Unfortunately, I am not aware of any good comprehensive book on Acol that goes to the next level. There used to be some good texts (two books by Eric Crowhurst for example), but they are all now very dated and haven’t aged well. There is a large gap in the market for someone to write a comprehensive text, but almost nobody plays Acol at the very highest level any more. Systems have become very complicated, usually based around a strong no trump and five-card majors with game forcing two-over-one bids and often transfer response structures. This is all very well, but it is not the sort of system that I would advise for a newer player.

          If you are looking for good books on card play and defence, there are many good books and they don’t become out-of-date in the way that bidding texts do. Any book by Reese will give excellent advice on card play and defence (but don’t take much notice of the bidding!).

          in reply to: Weak Two in 3rd seat (Bd 9 Wed Teams) #24964
          Brian DaviesBrian Davies
          Participant

            I know several players who would open three hearts on that hand!

            Brian DaviesBrian Davies
            Participant

              Have a look at the four hands and decide what contract you would like to play in. Your best fits are only seven-card fits in hearts and clubs, so maybe you choose no trump’s? Then try and work out how many tricks you might take. If things go well you might take 5 or even 6 tricks, but it is almost impossible to imagine you making 1NT and if the opponent’s defend well you should probably go down by three tricks.

              You should be very pleased that you passed here.

              in reply to: Bidding Quiz 41 #24936
              Brian DaviesBrian Davies
              Participant

                Colin, the terms Natural and Inviting to describe 4NT bid in this context are synonymous.  The bid would show a hand that is balanced (or semi-balanced) with a good stop in the opponent’s suit, but since it is above game level it is inviting slam.

                Interestingly, I checked with my two regular partner’s. Neither thought that 4NT would be ace-asking, but they came up with two different answers! One thought that it was natural, but the other suggested that it was showing 5-5 in the minors and wanting the doubler to bid five of their better minor. It makes some sense because it is sometimes necessary to double a preempt with hands that are a little off-shape.

                in reply to: Suit combinations #24881
                Brian DaviesBrian Davies
                Participant

                  I use Suitplay and you can still download the software – simply Google Suitplay, go to the site and follow the instructions.

                  in reply to: New search #24874
                  Brian DaviesBrian Davies
                  Participant

                    Thanks for highlighting this Robin and thanks to those who developed.

                    in reply to: Strong hand with Misfit #24844
                    Brian DaviesBrian Davies
                    Participant

                      Thanks Julian. Do you prefer a two spade rebid or a two diamond rebid as West? We play the two diamonds as 100% forcing after a 2 over 1 response.

                      in reply to: one that got away #24764
                      Brian DaviesBrian Davies
                      Participant

                        Your auction certainly seems to show the 6-6 shape – if all of the bids are natural.

                        But arguably, a jump shift response in diamonds, then rebidding the suit sets diamonds as trumps. And if it doesn’t, then surely a further rebid of diamonds sets the trump suit?

                         

                        in reply to: do you open 2S #24760
                        Brian DaviesBrian Davies
                        Participant

                          It is easy to be wise, seeing all four hands. But having the 10 and 9 to bolster the king of spades is enough for me. I would open 2S in first or third seat and I would consider it in second seat. Sometimes you get burnt, but I think that bidding these hands is the long-term winner.

                          John makes a good point about the 1NT bid in the second auction. Maybe South felt that he had a diamond stop?!

                          in reply to: A Tale So Tall That It May Even Be True. #24732
                          Brian DaviesBrian Davies
                          Participant

                            Nice story John – thanks.

                            On a serious note, this is the second post recently mentioning Lightner Doubles, but I am not convinced that this is a Lightner Double situation. A Lightner Double of a NT contract is unusual, but I guess it is possible. But the usual rule is that Lightner Doubles don’t apply when a the bidding is competitive. Sometimes you need to double to punish the opponents for stealing your contract or to stop partner bidding again as a sacrifice.

                            Here is a hand that I played last week:

                            Screenshot 2021-04-04 105200

                            You may not like the bidding. I was East and 4NT was a two-suiter (usually the minors).  5NT was probably too much, but equally might partner should arguably have bid 6D herself. The diamond slam is a great contract and three pairs bid it (twice doubled – interestingly!). Unfortunately, at our table they bid on to six hearts. I need to double to get something out of the hand and six hearts doubled should go three-off for 800, beating any pair in five diamonds. Unfortunately, we didn’t get the defence right – partner led the ace of spades, then switched to a club for +500.

                            But the double of a slam is needed to extract the maximum penalty in this sort of situation, so can’t be Lightner.

                            in reply to: Rebid #24696
                            Brian DaviesBrian Davies
                            Participant

                              Why is double such a bad idea? South might 2H or 2S. Partner won’t rush to bid clubs since this entails going to the three level, but I would expect partner to have five or six clubs if they do.

                              But the best outcome is that partner passes for penalties. In this seat and at this vulnerability, I would want a good reason for not doubling.

                              in reply to: Lightner Double #24417
                              Brian DaviesBrian Davies
                              Participant

                                Sorry, I hadn’t read Bernard’s reply when I started to draft mine. I think that he is saying the same thing.

                                in reply to: Lightner Double #24416
                                Brian DaviesBrian Davies
                                Participant

                                  Hi Charles,

                                  I have just played the hand. It was an interesting hand.

                                  I’m not sure that many would count me as an expert, but I will offer a comment anyway. You could play that a double is lead directing for dummy’s first suit, but that is not the usual interpretation of a Lightner Double. The Lightner Double was first proposed by Theodore Lightner and traditionally it asks partner to find an unusual lead. Sally Horton (now Sally Brock) in her book Double Trouble quotes two possibilities:

                                  1. We have a void somewhere and would like to be given an immediate ruff.
                                  2. We do not have a void, but our values are not where our partner is likely to expect them and thus suggests an unusual lead.

                                  On this hand, a diamond is clearly the “Usual Lead” and the one to avoid, so the choice would come down to a heart or a club. As West, with four hearts after South has shown heart length, I would lead a heart after East doubles expecting partner to ruff (or hold ♥AK). I guess that there is an argument that partner might have doubled 5♥ for a lead, so the double of 6♠ is asking for a club lead. But it is risky on ♣KQ, when South has shown length in both majors and might be expected to be short in clubs.

                                  But Sally Horton also states in her “Points to Remember” that partnership agreement in this area is much more important than the actual agreement itself. So I guess that as long as you and partner are aligned that double means “lead dummy’s first bid suit”, then I guess that it is reasonable. It is also consistent with a standard double of 3NT, so it is easy to remember.

                                Viewing 15 posts - 556 through 570 (of 1,123 total)